What is the full list of Shia accepted Quran translations/commentary? Also, which translations/commentary do Shias not accept (if any)?
You are here
Quran and Tafsir
While in classes for learning Qur'an, is it allowable for a woman, during menstruation, to read/recite the 4 surahs with obligatory sujood (this is with a Sunni teacher with whom sujood is not mandatory)?
This to not make this personal issue obvious and also not to call attention to the fact that I am Shia when doing so might cause ill feelings.
Jazakum Allahu Khairun.
thank u for the kind service.
I would like to ask about the commentary and application of the second verse of sura Asr, which states surely man is in loss. I tried to search in enlightening commentary -English, but did not give me a satisfying answer. other commentary are silent.
could you pls explain the following in the light of this verse with some references and quotation from masumeen (as) , that would also help me in understanding and quoting .
1. what is this loss ?? loss of what ? health , wealth, or ?
Why was the Quran not compiled in the order that it was revealed?
my Question is regarding the Tafseer of the following verse: Shakir 38:44] And take in your hand a green branch and beat her with It and do not break your oath; surely We found him patient; most excellent the servant! Surely he was frequent m returning (to Allah). [Pooya/Ali Commentary 38:44]
For fulfilment of his oath, Ayyub was directed by Allah to strike his wife one simple blow with a palm-branch having a hundred leaves. Kindly assist in explaining my limited understanding on the verse considering the following points.
Sir Please before direction of kaba (bait ullah) what was the direction and where intruction change direction.
thank you for the service.
I would like to ask about the miracle of Prophet Dawud (as) and the permissibility of music and singing.
I understand the said prophet was given the miracle of a sweet voice to do dhikr of god , but recently some misguided so called scholars have misinterpreted this miracle saying , P. dawud (as) was singing (naudhubillah !) till the birds used to come and hear his melodious voice, so,
singing is indeed a gift from god and not haraam ?
the said prophet (naudhubillah) liked music (mausuki) ?
Then did they feel secure from the plan of Allah ? But no one feels secure from the plan of Allah except the losing people.(Holy Quran 7:99)
My Question is, do Humans have to feel threatened that Allah swt would ever scheme a bad plan so as to leave them in ruins either physically or spiritually?? or what is the correct interpretation of this Ayah??
Was the quran revealed in the order what we have today ie chapter and verse from the begin to the end